PSA: Don't leave negative reviews for non-widescreen apps -- developers are updating as fast as they can!

PSA: Don't leave negative reviews for non-widescreen apps -- developers are updating as fast as they can! | iMore.com Skip to main content AndroidBlackBerryiPhone / iPadWindows PhonewebOS

Join our iPhone, iPod touch, iPad and Apple TV community today!   Register or Login Here

iMore iPhone iPad Forums Apps Accessories Reviews How-To Podcasts Free wallpapers: iPhone & iPad Guides: iOS, iCloud, Siri, photography, jailbreak Free: iPhone apps & games, iPad apps & games Shop Online Cases Chargers Screen protectors Headsets & More Free shipping on orders over $50 PSA: Don't leave negative reviews for non-widescreen apps -- developers are updating as fast as they can! By Rene Ritchie, Friday, Sep 21, 2012 a 12:13 am 7

At some point today, many of us will be tearing open our just-arrived Fedex or UPS packages, or rushing out of the Apple Store or other retailer, unboxing our brand new iPhones -- the iPhone 5 -- restoring them from iCloud, and launching our favorite App Store apps and games... only to see some with letter- and pillar-boxes.

Of course, a ton of really popular apps have already been updated and will be ready to go a launch. But other will take some time. So, before anyone jumps into comments or forums, or takes to Twitter, App.net, or Facebook -- or even thinks about leaving a bad App Store review -- to voice their frustrations over the lack of instant updates, there are a few realities to take into account, and some expectations that need to be properly set.

Why is this a thing?

With the iPhone 5 (and the iPod touch 5, shipping in October), Apple has changed the aspect ratio of the screen for the very first time. It's gone from the 2:3 that it's been since the original iPhone shipped in 2007 -- that persisted through the iPhone 4S in 2011 -- to 16:9. To do that, the iPhone 5 is adding 176 new pixels, taking the resolution from 960x640 to 1136x640. That means developers and designers need to figure out what to do with those extra pixels.

Can't it "just work"?

There's nothing automatic here for anyone here. No app will magically stretch to fill the new, longer iPhone 5 screen anymore than any app magically doubled in pixel density to look sharp on the iPhone 4 and iPad 3 Retina displays. The reason for that is simple -- Apple can't assume an app is built to support 16:9, so they'd rather letter- and pillar-box everything rather than risk having an app looking terrible or breaking if forced to fill a screen it was never designed to fill.

But that means it'll take some work to update apps. Depending on the app, maybe a little, and maybe a lot.

So how do apps become "widescreen ready"?

At a minimum, developers and designers will have to indicate their apps support 16:9, compile them against the iOS 6 SDK, include a special graphics file that tells iOS they're widescreen ready, and then submit them to Apple for (re-)approval.

For apps that use lists or grids, and/or implement a lot of standard controls and automatic layouts, flowing content into the longer (or wider) screen will likely be a lot easier than apps that use heavily customized interfaces.

For developers of apps and games alike who don't just want to show more of the same stuff, but take advantage of the extra screen space to provide different stuff the process will be even more involved.

Also keep in mind that developers will continue to have to support the 3:2 aspect ratio of the still-for-sale iPhone 4, iPod touch 4, and iPhone 4S. Interface elements can't simply be cropped off on older devices. Pixel-perfect designers and developers will want their interfaces pixel-perfect on every screen supported by iOS 6.

Add to that, very few developers and designers have actually been able to see, much less test on an actual iPhone 5 yet. Aside from the apps shown off by Apple at the iPhone 5 event, it's a safe bet next to no one has. A lot of developers and designers are smart and experienced enough to use the tools Apple has provided to prepare and update anyway, but no one likes to launch an app that they haven't been able to run, hold, and hammer away at on real hardware.

Lastly, given how many apps will no doubt be submitted to the App Store this week in anticipation of iOS 6 and the iPhone 5 launch, even if this work itself is quick, the approval process could well be a bottleneck.

Apple will want to showcase "widescreen ready" apps, the way they've showcased "Retina ready" apps previously, so they'll work as fast as they can, but there are limits to everything.

How do you know developers are actually working on it?

Gedeon Maheux of the Iconfactory

A number of iOS clients have already contacted us about updating their apps for the new, taller iPhone 5 screen. From the moment it was announced, the Iconfactory started including these new UI requirements into our workflow. I suspect it won't take long before we start to see many of your favorite apps updated and ready.

Davd Barnard of App Cubby:

Apple works incredibly hard to make sure that things work as expected for developers, and I’m hopeful that this will be an incredibly smooth transition. However, it’s still a risk for developers to just blindly support a new screen size and architecture without being able to fully test on actual hardware. We can test in the iOS simulator, but the simulator is — as the name would suggest — just a simulation of what the app will be like on an actual device. Over the years I’ve found quite a few bugs on a device that can’t be replicated in the simulator. Not to mention UI issues. The simulator just can’t replicate the feel of swiping, tapping, and other key aspects of touch-screen apps. It’s tough to know how an app is going to feel until it’s under your fingers.

Bottom line, it’s risky to support a device I haven’t tested on. But, given Apple’s track record of managing these transitions well, and the minimal amount of code we had to change, we decided the risk was worth taking. We’ve already submitted 3 App Cubby apps (Launch Center Pro, Timer, and Mirror) and will be working hard on Gas Cubby and Trip Cubby this week.

Marc Edwards of Bjango

We've completed the work required for Consume and iStat 2 to support the iPhone 5's taller display. We needed five images for Consume and one for iStat. All up, it was a few hours work each. Some apps will require more work, but this is far less painful than the non-Retina to Retina transition. The big caveat is that we haven't done any device testing yet, but that's the same as most developers.

So what can we expect when we get our Phone 5 ?

When you get your iPhone 5, and all your apps have downloaded, some of them will support 16:9, and some of them will do it well. If you see a letter- or pillar-box, however, before you complain -- and most especially before you leave a negative review -- take a moment. Take a moment to consider that the developers and designers love their apps and hate seeing them boxed even more than you do. Consider that they're probably working around the clock to get their updates done, working blindly do to it, and waiting patiently and powerlessly for Apple to approve them. They'll get them to you just as fast as they can.

Give developers or designers a few weeks or a month to get their basic updates done and approved by Apple, and then, if any apps look abandoned or look like they're going to go without an update, you can let 'em have it.

Rene Ritchie

Editor-in-Chief of iMore,co-host of Iterate and ZEN and TECH podcasts. Cook, grappler, photon wrangler.

Follow @reneritchie !function(d,s,id){var js,fjs=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];if(!d.getElementById(id)){js=d.createElement(s);js.id=id;js.src="//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js";fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js,fjs);}}(document,"script","twitter-wjs");

More Posts

 

1 1 93 More of: News
More of: ios 6, Iphone 5, widescreen ready ? PreviouslyiFixIt commences their iPhone 5 teardown Next up ?The best games to show off your new iPhone 5 There are 7 comments. Add yours. nerdshowandtell says: Sep 21, 2012 at 3:03 am - 5 hours ago

lol, so its ok to give bad reviews for android tablets and apps, but when your precious iOS/Apple has Fragmentation its OK!.. so it just works, just not right away, and only when apple says so.

Reply nikkisharif says: Sep 21, 2012 at 3:49 am - 5 hours ago

lol

Reply Rene Ritchie says: Sep 21, 2012 at 4:16 am - 4 hours ago

We're talking about negative reviews of apps in the App Store -- something that effects a developers livelihood -- over something for which they have little control.

Go leave all the negative reviews for Apple you like.

(Or next time read the post before trolling...)

Reply siddo_d says: Sep 21, 2012 at 3:15 am - 5 hours ago

Fair enough

Reply 640p says: Sep 21, 2012 at 5:47 am - 3 hours ago

Ok Rene we'll do whatever you say Hitler. Don't want to give any bad reviews to any apps. We must all assume that every single dev will fix these disaster letterbox issues. Can we give bad reviews to Passport and Maps? Or should we wait until Apple fixes them?

Reply togardergrosse says: Sep 21, 2012 at 7:23 am - 1 hour ago

LOL'd to this...

Reply dloveprod says: Sep 21, 2012 at 7:04 am - 1 hour ago

It seems like this time the most apps were ready for the new iPhone release compared to all the others. I kinda wanna see what an app looks like letterboxed.

Reply Contact iMoreSEND US NEWS  |  SUBMIT AN APP

Shop iMore

THE #1 ACCESSORY STORE | 2 MILLION+ ORDERS SHIPPED

Browse All Accessories Cases and Skins Chargers Cradles Bluetooth Headsets Screen Protectors See all accessories Browse Accessories For Your Phone iPhone 4S Cases Chargers Car Kits & more The new iPad Cases Chargers Screen Care & more iPhone 4 Cases Chargers Car Kits & more iPad 2 Cases Chargers Screen Care & more iPhone 3GS Cases Chargers Car Kits & more iPad Cases Chargers Screen Care & more Shop iMore

THE #1 ACCESSORY STORE | 2 MILLION+ ORDERS SHIPPED

View All Devices STORE AD CONTENT Follow iMore(function(d, s, id) { var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; if (d.getElementById(id)) return; js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id; js.src = "//connect.facebook.net/en_US/all.js#xfbml=1&appId=213678485361751"; fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);}(document, 'script', 'facebook-jssdk'));

Follow @iMore!function(d,s,id){var js,fjs=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];if(!d.getElementById(id)){js=d.createElement(s);js.id=id;js.src="//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js";fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js,fjs);}}(document,"script","twitter-wjs");


Facebook
Twitter
Google+
RSS
YouTube
iTunes Wear iMore Download iMoreiMORE APP  |  iMORE FORUMS  |  MOBILE NATIONS

Watch iMoreMORE SHOWS  |  MORE VIDEOS

Tell iMore
Team iMore
Rene
Georgia
Leanna
Chris
Ally
Simon
Chris
Michelle Headlines iPhone 5 launch live from the Regent Street Apple Store in London iPhone 5 London launch gallery How to track your iPhone 5 delivery if you’re in the UK PSA: Don't leave negative reviews for non-widescreen apps -- developers are updating as fast as they can! All headlines Help & how-to How to setup and start using your new iPhone 5 How to add a location or report a problem in iOS 6 Maps How to put your iPad into "Guest User" mode with Guided Access How to manually update to iOS 6 over-the-air (OTA) All help & how-to Apps & games The best games to show off your new iPhone 5 Rovio's Bad Piggies appear in first gameplay trailer Verticus is Stan Lee's first iOS game iTunes and App Store get major facelifts for iPhone 5 All apps & games Accessories Zooka Bluetooth Wireless Speaker review iMore Editors' Choice for September 16, 2012 iControlPad 2 hits Kickstarter with full keyboard, game controls, and open source Win a FREE Jot Touch Bluetooth pressure sensitive stylus from Adonit and iMore! Enter Now! All accessories iPhone iPhone 5 launch live from Apple Store Montreal iPhone 5 launch live from the Regent Street Apple Store in London iPhone 5 London launch gallery iMore show 314: iOS 6 review + iPhone 5 buyers guide All iphone More iPad iPhone 5 launch live from Apple Store Montreal iPhone 5 launch live from the Regent Street Apple Store in London iPhone 5 London launch gallery iMore show 314: iOS 6 review + iPhone 5 buyers guide All more ipad iOS 5 + iCloud iPhone 5 launch live from Apple Store Montreal iPhone 5 launch live from the Regent Street Apple Store in London iPhone 5 London launch gallery iMore show 314: iOS 6 review + iPhone 5 buyers guide All ios 5 + icloud Jailbreak State of the jailbreak: iOS 6, iPhone 5, and more How to tethered jailbreak iOS 6 and install Cydia Add page animations and transitions to your iPhone or iPad with DisplayCandy [jailbreak] Dash brings fluid card style multitasking to your iPhone [jailbreak] All jailbreak Device reviews The new iPad (2012) review iPhone 4S review 2011 iPod touch review White iPhone 4 review All device reviews Comparisons iPhone 5 vs. Samsung Galaxy S3: Which phone should you get? Apple iPhone 5 vs Samsung Galaxy S3 vs HTC One X vs. BlackBerry 10 vs. Nokia Lumia 920: Spec Shootout! Google Nexus 7 vs. iPad 3, unboxing and first impressions -- from iMore! Apple iPad or Google Nexus 7: Which one should you get? All comparisons Features iOS 6 will be good for Apple... eventually Forums: WiFi woes, Siri on the iPad and is swapping colors an option? Forums: Waiting in line, Still flabbergasted that they called it the iPhone 5 Forums: Apple Care, Waiting for launch day, Case or no case for your iPhone 5? All features Contests Announcing the winner of the FREE iPhone 5... And a 2nd chance to win! Weekly Photo Contest: Panoramas with iOS 6! Contest Winners: Pad & Quill cases and the Jot Touch stylus from Adonit! Here's your chance for a bonus entry on Facebook in iMore's Follow and Win giveaway! All contests Mobile Nations YouTube Channel Follow Us on Twitter Join us on Facebook Mobile Nations RSS Feed 8,381,907 Readers Per Month Mobile Nations brings you the very best of Android Central,
CrackBerry, iMore, webOS Nation, and WPCentral   iOS 6 reviewApple releases iOS 6 for iPhone, iPod touch, and iPadHow to manually update to iOS 6 over-the-air (OTA)How to update iPhone, iPad, and iPod touch to iOS 6 via iTunesDeal of the Day: 50% off Seidio SURFACE Reveal Case for iPhone 4S and iPhone 4Counting down to iOS 6!   Samsung's latest commercial: The next big thing is already hereT-Mobile U.S.A. announces John Legere as new CEOLive from New York City with HTC!Motorola RAZR i initial video reviewDeal of the Day: Seidio ACTIVE Case for Samsung Galaxy NoteThe Samsung Galaxy Note 2 will hit 5 US carriers by mid-November BlackBerry 10 L-Series gets a early hands-on teardownWant some funky new sound effects on your BlackBerry? Check out Sound Effects FreeBlackBerry theme roundup - September 19, 2012Deal of the Day: Save 52% on the iGrip Headrest TABLET Kit for Blackberry PlayBookLeaked OS 7.1.0.714 for the BlackBerry Torch 9860 Team behind HTC 8x for Windows Phone 8 explain that iconic designHTC 8X Windows Phone joins the T-Mobile lineupHTC 8X Windows Phone headed to AT&THTC 8X and 8S Windows Phones both heading to Three UKTrade in your old phone for up to $300 with HTC's new "Trade Up" programPoll - Which HTC 8X Windows Phone colour would you choose? ZTE to launch Firefox OS smartphone, not webOSMaybe it's time to stop hating on HP?ScienceApps going all-in on LunaCE with stack launching and big notifications [video]What would a webOS smartphone need to be competitive today?App Giveaway: sinceWhen+TouchPad Go charity raffle gets a little sweeter   iPhone / iPad ForumsAndroid ForumsBlackBerry ForumsWindows Phone ForumswebOS Forums Copyright 2012 Mobile Nations ? Terms and Conditions ? Privacy Policy

View the original article here